Should a US restaurant take orders directly instead of through third-party apps?
For most independents the question is not apps or no apps, but which orders should go where.
Short answer
- Most US restaurants do best with both: apps for discovery and direct ordering for repeat guests.
- Direct orders avoid the per-order commission, which on Uber Eats ranges from 20% to 30% for delivery (Lite can be lower in some cities).
- With direct orders you own the guest list and can tell regulars about specials or catering.
- Pickup is the easiest place to start, because you do not need drivers.
- For delivery you use your own drivers or a courier service you choose, and you set the fee and zone.
Who does what
Third-party app vs direct ordering site
| Point | Third-party app | Direct ordering site |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Commission per order | Subscription, no per-order commission |
| Guest data | Held by the app | Your own list |
| Menu prices | Often marked up | Your in-store prices |
| Delivery | App drivers | Your drivers or chosen courier |
Example from Denver
A Denver pizzeria moves its Friday regulars to pickup on its own site with a printed QR code in every app bag. 120 direct pickup orders a month at $28 save about $235 compared with a 7% pickup fee, and much more compared with delivery commission.
Common mistakes
- Hiding the direct ordering link on page three of the website.
- Offering delivery to a radius the kitchen cannot serve hot.
- Turning off apps before direct orders are steady.
How to start
Start with pickup on your own site, because it needs no drivers and no new staff. Add delivery in a small radius once pickup orders are steady. Keep the same menu prices on your site as in store, and use app bags, receipts and your Google Business Profile to point guests to the direct link.
How 4salefood helps
- Ready templates for restaurants, pizza, fast food and desserts with menu, cart and checkout under your own domain.
- Delivery and pickup are separate order modes.
- The menu is a normal URL, so you can print a QR code to it yourself.
Sources
Content and sources checked on .